In some ways, rental properties are like reptiles. They don’t need to be fed every day, but periodically, they do require a rather substantial meal.
For example, let’s say that you have a pretty decent rental with about $200 per month in positive cash flow. Great! That’s $2,400 extra dollars of income a year! But…not so fast. This extra money is critical to your success as an investor, but it should be looked at as part of the reserve you should keep on hand to feed your rental when it gets hungry.
So, let’s say that in your pretty decent rental, you have a pretty decent tenant that pays their rent on time every month for two years. Great! That’s $4,800 extra dollars in the bank. But, like I said before, not so fast. During these two years, you were only plagued periodically with small maintenance items. There was a little trouble with some ants which cost you $95 in pest control. Then the plumber had to pay a visit – that was $200. And, of course, the furnace needed to be serviced which ran you close to $300.
Still, not so bad, $595 from your $4,800 leaves you up $4,205. But then your tenant moves out. The good news is that a portion of their security deposit covers the clean up as was mandated in the lease. The bad news is that you need to replace the carpet and that’s going to cost you about $1,500. Between getting it fixed up and placing a qualified new tenant, your rental ends up sitting vacant for about a month, which means another $700 going out for your mortgage payment.
But still, you’re at a healthy $2,005 profit for this property. Not too bad. But then, and here’s the kicker, a nasty winter storm blows through and causes the roof to sprout a leak. The contractor comes out and tells you that your roof was already in poor condition, and it’s time to put a whole new roof on.
The cost for this? $5,000. Ouch. No more profits left, you come out of pocket $2,995 because, after two years of sparse meals, your rental property is hungry.
What exactly am I trying to say here? Only this: investing in rental real estate is a long term commitment.
Should you acquire properties that cash flow? Absolutely! Should you expect this cash flow to supplement your income in the short term? Probably not, unless you either got an extraordinarily good deal (above and beyond what most investors get), or you put a significant amount of money down.
Investing in rental real estate has many benefits, but, in my opinion, short term income is usually not one of them.
Until my next post,
James
P.S. An alternative to this scenario is to make money investing in real estate with very high cash flow properties or deals structured to produce very high cash flow as we teach to our Real Estate Investor Bronze Members. Or, consider making money investing in real estate with wholesaling or virtual wholesaling.
As both an active real estate investor and a currently inactive real estate broker associate who catered to investors, I have the conversation about Flipping versus Buy and Hold a lot.
So, I wanted to share with you some insight into the differences I see between the two.
First, I need to admit that I am primarily a buy and hold investor, but I do occasionally fix and flip a property to supplement cash flow needs. I am moving move towards quick turning properties.
With that being said, here is how I see the differences between buying property to immediately resell or buying properties for long-term wealth accumulation.
Buying properties to resell immediately requires that you have systems and a team in place to help you purchase, fix up/rehab, market and sell properties.
Buying properties as long-term rentals requires that you have a team to help you purchase, fix-up the property for tenants, and get houses rented. Either you need a property manager to manage your tenants or you need to manage your properties directly. Even with a property manager, you still need to manage him or her to make sure he/she is performing the job satisfactorily.
In my experience, a fix and flip property requires more personal interaction. I find myself more involved with handling the purchase, and overseeing the rehab and sales process. On the other hand, my experience with acquiring rental properties takes very little of my time. Perhaps this is because I have great teams already in place.
The biggest difference between buying houses for fix and flip versus buy and hold comes down to finances. Both require cash or access to cash via credit or a partner, but rental properties that you buy to hold long term with relatively high levels of debt, typically don’t produce a significant amount of income in the short run. In fact, having a positive cash flow of $100 to $200 a month, when you factor in repairs between tenants and improvements to the property like the occasional roof, means that you really don’t have any cash flow at all when you look at the numbers over a period of several years.
On the other hand, buying to fix and flip can generate chunks of cash relatively quickly… in a few months on a fast rehab and sale. Wholesaling properties can generate cash even faster.
So, if you are trying to generate immediate profits, I suggest looking at buying to fix and flip. If you have income from another source and are looking at real estate as a wealth building asset, I would strongly suggest you consider long term buy and hold.
Until my next post,
James
P.S. We teach a variety of short term solutions to cash flow and long term wealth building strategies to our Real Estate Investor Bronze Members. Sign up today to access a wealth of training materials (over 100 real estate courses) plus on-going training and free real estate investor consulting sessions.

